Coach claims transfer violates First Amendment rights | TCTA
Share this page:
Gavel, law books and scales of justice

Coach claims transfer violates First Amendment rights

Share this page:

A Texas coach and teacher refused to shake the hands of several school board members and employees during a celebration for a team he coached. He claimed he did this because he personally disliked the individuals and also did not want to appear to endorse the board members politically. 

After this incident, the district transferred him to a position at another school. The teacher and his family sued the district, claiming the transfer was retaliation and a violation of his constitutional rights.

A U.S. district court dismissed his claims under the First Amendment because the teacher “acted ‘during his official duties in the course and scope of his employment,’ not as a private citizen, when he refused to shake” the board members’ and employees’ hands. The teacher appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.

The court of appeals said that the coach’s refusal to shake hands occurred when he was acting “in his capacity as a public employee.” The incident occurred when the teacher was acting as a coach, accompanying his team, and attending a board meeting that he was invited to in his official capacity. 

The court further noted that the speech was directed “internally ‘up the chain of command’” and not “externally.” Therefore, the court concluded that the teacher’s speech “was directly governed by school policy.” 

Accordingly, even if the district’s reassignment was punishment for the teacher’s actions, the district did not violate the teacher's First Amendment rights.