Home ::

Legislation passed during the 2005 legislative session imposes new requirements on districts for dealing with students who sexually assault, harass or bully other students. One of the new measures defines bullying and requires a school district to transfer a bullying victim, upon parental request, to a different classroom or campus. Another new statute places requirements on school districts to transfer students who have sexually assaulted other students. Finally, teachers should also be aware of their responsibilities and liabilities in the event of student-to-student sexual harassment.

Bullying

This new law, which was supported by TCTA, defines bullying as written or verbal expression or conduct that the school board determines will have the effect of physically harming a student, damaging property or placing a student in fear of harm to him/her self or his/her property, or is severe enough to create an intimidating, threatening or abusive educational environment. It requires a school district to transfer a bullying victim, upon parental request, to a different classroom or campus. It mandates that the student code of conduct prohibit bullying, harassment and “hit lists” and ensure that employees enforce the prohibitions; the code also must provide methods for managing bullying and disciplining students. A special education student may not be disciplined for such conduct until an ARD meeting has been held to review the conduct. 

Mandatory transfer of students involved in a sexual assault

Another new bill approved during the 2005 legislative session and that was supported by TCTA relates to the mandatory transfer of students involved in a sexual assault. It provides that a student who is the victim of aggravated sexual assault or sexual assault by another student at the same campus must, upon parental request, be transferred to a different campus than the offender or to a neighboring school district. If the victim chooses not to transfer, the board must transfer the offender to a different campus, or an AEP or JJAEP if there is only one campus in the district at that grade level. 

Student-to-student sexual harassment

The existing law pertaining to student-to-student sexual harassment is codified in Davis v. Monroe County Board of Education. In Davis, the United States Supreme Court rejected claims against teacher employees because the case was filed under Title IX, which imposes liability only on educational institutions that discriminate based on gender and deny access to the benefits of an education. Sexual harassment is a form of gender discrimination.

It is important to note that the Court held in Davis that a parent could sue a school district for student-to-student sexual harassment if severe, persistent and highly offensive sexual misconduct impedes a student’s access to the benefits of an education, and the school district, with actual knowledge of the harassment, acted unreasonably in failing to stop the misconduct. Because of this, TCTA members should pay attention to the following:

  • School district policies prohibiting peer sexual harassment require employees who have knowledge of non-minor sexual harassment to report the conduct to a principal or to the district’s Title IX coordinator. Most of these policies do not distinguish “minor” from “non-minor” misconduct. Therefore, if any question exists, an employee should report as required to a principal or preferably to the Title IX coordinator.
  • Sexual harassment can occur among students of the same or opposite gender. Some district policies define sexual harassment to include sexual misconduct directed at a student solely on the basis of orientation.
  • A victim of sexual harassment may ask you to not report the harassment, however that request does not release you from the requirements of the law and board policy.

If peer harassment rises to the level of child abuse, failure to report such abuse to Child Protective Services within 48 hours (800-252-5400) may put a teacher in legal and employment jeopardy. Even failure to report as required by district policy could expose a teacher to a reprimand, or worse.

The Department of Education, Office for Civil Rights has published an excellent discussion about this topic: “Revised Sexual Harassment Guidance: Harassment of Students by Employees, Other Students, or Third Parties” available online from the Department of Education Web site (click on “Reading Room”).

Call with concerns

TCTA members should use common sense and comply with policies and the law if aware of bullying or sexually inappropriate conduct among peers or teachers and students. If a TCTA member is being harassed or is aware of harassment, or has questions about the new requirements related to students who bully or sexually assault other students, the member can contact the TCTA legal staff at (888) 879-8282 to discuss options and obligations.